2021 Tesla Model Y Performance

VIN 5YJYGDEFXMF133844

Typical market price

$28,083

91 comparable listings

This vehicle is no longer listed. The figures below describe the market for this build.

Compare alternatives from other brands ↓

Last listed by Carz4Us Pine Brook

20 Us 46, Pine Brook, NJ 07058

Hours

Mon–Sat: 10:00 AM – 7:00 PM

This VIN is no longer listed by this dealer. They may still have a similar vehicle — ask.

Call (888) 928-3858

Get directions carz4usauto.com

This car on VehiSales ↗

Contact details come from the dealer's listing and public business records. VinAssessment is not the seller and takes no fee — you deal with the dealer directly.

VehiLeaks · Vehicle Report

Know this Model Y before you buy.

Check reported accidents, title issues, mileage records and past listings for this VIN.

✓ Reported accidents & damage
✓ Title brands — salvage, flood, lemon
✓ Odometer readings over time
✓ Every past listing: price, dealer, photos

Get vehicle report — $6

One-time payment · No subscription

Inside your report

VIN report

2021 Tesla Model Y Performance

VIN 5YJYGDEFXMF133844

Accidents Reported damage & accident records

Title Salvage, flood & other title brands

Mileage Recorded odometer readings

Listings Past prices, dealers & listing photos

Section preview · Results shown in the full report

Report for this VIN · 5YJYGDEFXMF133844

vehileaks.com →

Market price range

Based on 91 comparable same-build listings · Market data as of September 23, 2026

Below market

$24,494

Typical price

$28,083

Above market

$32,995

See all 2021 Tesla Model Y prices — typical $28,083 →

THE SMARTER NEXT STEP

Love this car? See what else is out there.

2021 Tesla Model Y Performance for sale near Pine BrookNJ

59 cheaper within 50 miles · best $11,642 less

4 same trim from $24,790 ▼ $3,701 less Ewing

20 from 2022, same body from $17,449 ▼ $11,042 less Paterson

60 one trim down from $16,849 ▼ $11,642 less Belleville

See all 84 cars near you →

Compare on VehiSales ↗ · No dealer spam.

We don't sell cars and never share your details with dealers.

Cars in your search area

50 miles around Pine Brook

Lower price Other cars Search center

This vehicle

Dots show approximate vehicle locations.

Vehicle locations appear when available.

Price history for this VIN

Price increased $1,000 (+3.6%) over 5 days.

Sep 6, 2026 · $27,491 Sep 11, 2026 · $28,491

Asking prices recorded across 2 listing dates for VIN 5YJYGDEFXMF133844, spanning 5 days.

Listings

Full listing history on VehiSales →

No active listings of this exact VIN right now.

Former listings

Dealer	Location	Price	Mileage	Listed	Seen
Carz4Us Pine Brook	Pine Brook, NJ 7058	$28,491	51,133 mi	2026-09-11	18 h ago
Carz4us of Pinebrook	Pine Brook, NJ 7058	$27,491	51,132 mi	2026-09-09	18 h ago
Carz 4 Us	South Hackensack, NJ 7606	$29,491	51,133 mi	2026-09-07	18 h ago
Carz4us of Pine Brook	Pine Brook, NJ 7058	$27,491	51,132 mi	2026-09-05	18 h ago

Decoded from the VIN

NHTSA build data for 5YJYGDEFXMF133844

Trim

Performance AWD

Drivetrain

All-Wheel Drive

Body

Sport Utility Vehicle [SUV]/Multipurpose Vehicle [MPV]

Fuel

Electric

Doors

Model year

2021

Made by

TESLA, INC.

Full factory specs for this build →

✗ Backup camera
✗ Blind-spot monitor
✗ Lane departure
✗ ABS
✗ Electronic stability

EPA efficiency (MPGe)

Combined

125

MPGe

City

131

MPGe

Highway

117

MPGe

Electric — running cost depends on local electricity rates, so no gallon-based estimate is shown.

5-year cost to own

Beyond the sticker: what this 2021 Tesla Model Y likely costs over five years at 15,000 mi/yr.

Depreciation $9,881

Fuel $4,150

Insurance $9,050

Maintenance & repairs $3,750

Total, 5 years $26,831

Estimate — insurance and taxes vary by driver and state.

Safety & recalls

NHTSA crash tests & recall campaigns for this model year

The 2021 Tesla Model Y has 23 recall campaigns as of August 2026. EPA combined rating: 125 MPGe.

23 recall campaigns on this model year

Check accident & title history →

ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

Tesla, Inc. (Tesla) is recalling certain 2016-2022 Model S and Model X, 2017-2022 Model 3, and 2020-2022 Model Y vehicles.

NHTSA campaign 22V037000
SUSPENSION

Tesla, Inc. (Tesla) is recalling certain 2020-2022 Model Y vehicles. The front and rear suspension knuckles may fracture, causing the suspension links to separate.

NHTSA campaign 21V912000
SUSPENSION

Tesla, Inc. (Tesla) is recalling certain 2020-2021 Model Y and 2019-2021 Model 3 vehicles.

NHTSA campaign 21V835000

Recall campaigns apply to the model year, not to one car. Check remedy status for this VIN at nhtsa.gov/recalls.

Model-level data for the 2021 Tesla Model Y from NHTSA (recalls, NCAP crash tests) and EPA fueleconomy.gov, refreshed August 27, 2026.

Where the price is heading

Typical asking price for a 2021 Tesla Model Y over the last 6 months — the market firmed $965 in that span.

Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep

Monthly price table

Month	Typical price
April 2026	$26,819
May 2026	$27,495
June 2026	$27,850
July 2026	$27,554
August 2026	$27,600
September 2026	$27,784

A little comparison goes a long way

What else could you drive?

Compare 2021 Tesla Model Y with other models from the same year. Choose the trims that matter to you.

About this comparison ↓

As of September 23, 2026, among alternatives (model years 2021–2022) to the 2021 Tesla Model Y in this catalog, the 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 has the lowest median asking price ($19,224, 119 listings with photos) and the 2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime (PHEV) the highest ($32,076, 95 listings).

Comparison catalog · Snapshot September 23, 2026, 05:00 UTC · Only listings with photos. This sample is separate from the price overview above and its figures differ.

The car you are viewing

2021 Tesla Model Y

Performance AWD · United States

$28,491

Catalog asking price for this VIN

All trims

$23,487

Median asking price · 106 qualifying listings

Middle 50%$20,990–$25,000

Find listings on VehiSales ↗

Actual GT-Line listing photo; individual equipment may differ.

Compare prices side by side

Asking prices for your current selection (USD)
Model / trim	Median	Middle 50%	Listings
2021 Tesla Model Y Performance AWD	$28,083	$26,041–$30,448	90
2022 Ford Mustang Mach-E All trims	$27,098	$24,500–$29,990	283
2021 Volkswagen ID.4 All trims	$19,224	$17,521–$20,998	119
2021 Toyota RAV4 Prime (PHEV) All trims	$32,076	$29,699–$35,251	95
2021 Audi Q5 E All trims	$25,574	$22,799–$27,998	40
2022 Kia EV6 All trims	$23,487	$20,990–$25,000	106

What these prices mean

Only catalog listings with photos are included. Trim names do not verify equivalent equipment. Prices are asking prices, not completed sales. Alternatives share the body style and class of the source model; the nearest model years are used when the same year has too few listings. Price differences are not a valuation adjustment or guaranteed savings.

Snapshot: September 23, 2026, 05:00 UTC. 3 source listings excluded by statistical price screening; this does not verify that every deposit or payment ad has been removed.

VehiSales opens in a new tab with the model, year and known mileage range. Confirm trim, fuel, drivetrain, condition and location on VehiSales; its live inventory may differ.

Market by model year

Gen 1 · 2020–present

What each model year costs right now — live supply, median asking price and how much value each year keeps versus the newest one.

Year	Units for sale	Median price	vs newest	Avg mileage
2026	612	$47,824	100%	12,364 mi
2025	339	$38,995	82%	28,994 mi
2024	711	$36,998	77%	37,269 mi
2023	1,371	$33,500	70%	44,458 mi
2022	1,176	$30,000	63%	63,586 mi
2021	824	$27,578	58%	71,800 mi
2020	269	$26,977	56%	72,555 mi